Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leighton Trainer's avatar

True love? More like unhealthy obsession. Can we stop treating this guy like he was a knight in shining armour? Dude bullied his students to the point where one of them (Neville Longbottom) has his bogart turn into him. On top of that, he was a murderer, most likely a mass murderer. He didn't do what he did for Harry out of "love." He did it because of this obsession with Lily and, if you remember correctly, didn't give a shit about Harry or James when Voldemort targeted the Potters. He just wanted Lily. And Dumbledore called him out on this. It was only then that he, reluctantly, agreed to protect James and Harry. I won't go as far as to say he is badly written, like another commenter, but he is not supposed to be a good person. Perhaps he could have been, but he chose to go down the dark path. Sure, he kind of redeems himself, but that doesn't justify his behaviour. If he really wanted to redeem himself, he wouldn't have bullied fucking children! All this crap with him and Lily? Stop it. James was a better fit with her for a reason and it's not just because Snape that one time called her a Mudblood. James straightened out. Snape didn't and he chose to be resentful and to seek vengeance on the world until it affected him. Guy's a selfish jerk, let's stop pretending he's the real hero. He ain't

Kathrine Elaine's avatar

My favourite HP character. James Potter was absolutely a swine. 😂

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?